|
Observations on Therapeutic
Effectiveness of Li's Prescription No.5 in
Treatment of Cerebral Palsy and Mental Retardation (Dementia) and
an Approach to Its Mechanism of Action
|
[Abstract] Objective The importance of control of hypophrenia and the
lack of effective remedies for the disease at present prompted the author
to make a thorough study on this problem and developed a traditional Chinese
medicinal prescription£ "Li's Prescription No.5". Very satisfactory
results were obtained with clinical application of the prescription. Reported
herein are the results of therapeutic observation and an approach to mechanism
of action of Li's Prescription No.5. Method Xu's ten-item oral-answer
test was used to test intelligence. Part of the patients were subjected
to EEG, CT and chromosome examinations before and after treatment to compare
therapeutic effectiveness. Only preparation of Li's Prescription No.5
was given to all the patients without any other drugs. Results Of the
1 396 patients with mental retardation, 1 253 showed marked effectiveness
after 2-4 courses of treatment and 143 showed effectiveness, the effective
rate being 100% and markedly effective rate being 89.8%. In no case was
toxic or side effect observed. Conclusions Clinical application showed
that Li's Prescription No.5 might be the ideal therapy for mental retardation
at present. The author advances the theory of "adjusting point"
on the development and functioning of human brain (Li's theory) and discusses
the mechanism of action of Li's Prescription No.5.
[Key words] Li's Prescription No.5 Cerebral palsy Mental retardation Hypophrenia
Li's theory
The prophylaxis and treatment of hypophrenia is one of the leading problems
of improving population quality. The morbidity rate of child hypophrenia
is about 3% abroad, 2%-3% in rural areas and 1% in cities of this country.
According to a preliminary investigation, there are about 24 million people
suffering from mental retardation (MR) in the 1 100 million people (1).
The disease is characterized mainly by developmental retardation of intelligence,
with intelligence quotient (IQ) below 70 points in most cases. Patients
with the disease are unable to adapt themselves to the objective requirements
in
Author's unit: Guangdong Gaoming Medical and Medicinal Institute of Encephalopathy,
2 Heping Lane, Cangjiang Road, Hecheng District, Gaoming, Guangdong 528500.
study, life and behaviors and bring about a heavy burden to the family
and society. At present, no satisfactory therapy is available. For more
than ten years, we have explored and studied the problem and made some
progress by using traditional Chinese medicine to treat hypophrenia. This
demonstrated that the intelligence of children with hypophrenia still
has the possibility to improve. By using self-made capsule of Li's Prescription
No.5 we have treated 1 396 MR children and achieved unexpected results.
Reported herein are the results of treatment.
Clinical data
General Data
Of the 1 396 MR children, aged 3-24 years, mean 15.6 years, 833 were males
and 563 were females; 92 were of mild type (dull-wittedness), 380 were
of moderate type (dementia) and 924 were of severe type (idiocy). Part
of the affected children had concomitant dysopia (27 cases), dyskinesia
(including paralysis, stiffness and ataxia, 382 cases) and epilepsy (264
cases). The vast majority of the affected children had been treated in
different places in many ways but they failed to respond to medical treatment.
One thousand and thirty cases had a history of difficult labor, delivery
suffocation, premature delivery, forceps delivery, 285 had a history of
high fever, convulsion and diarrhea, 4 cases had chromosome abnormalities,
and 77 cases had unknown causes.
Psychometric Method
The more complexity of the revised Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children
(WISC-R) prompted us to use the simple and easy Xu's oral-answer test
(2), the items of which are as follows: (1) count backwards from 30 to
1 and record the state of completeness and the speed; (2) recite in order
numerals, starting with five-digit number till nine-digit number, and
record the digit number recited; (3) conduct continued subtraction, for
children aged less than 8 years, use 30-3¡¡, for those aged more than
8 years, use 100-7¡¡, and record the state of completeness and the speed;
(4) differentiate things, make the children differentiate a chicken from
a duck, and record the state of completeness; (5) make the affected children
tell the kinds of colour they know and record them; (6) describe things,
let the affected children describe the contour of an elephant and record
the accuracy and totality; (7) do mathematical exercises, for example,
a pencil costs 13 cents, what's the money for 2 pencils? For children
aged 10 years or over, they may be asked: Fifty-nine apples are distributed
to 5 little friends, how many apples does everybody have? And how many
apples are left over? They are asked to do sums in their head. Record
the right or wrong answers; (8) explain uses, make the children explain
the uses of wood and record how many kinds of uses he can tell; (9) test
logic memory, let the children retell a about story and record the degree
of accuracy of retelling; and (10) making test of "shooting birds",
the children are asked how many birds are left over if one of the ten
birds on the tree is shooted to death.
The above-mentioned 10-items test had been tested in 200 school-age children
aged 7-13 years. Except the items 7 and 10 which should be evaluated according
to the correct or wrong answer, the remaining items are evaluated according
to the average value. If an affected child comes up to the level of average
value, he (she) is said to pass the test and given 10 points. If the total
score is below 40 points, the patient can be regarded as having oligophrenia
by taking his (her) case history into account. The total scores of the
1 396 children in this series were all below 40 points. Follow-up study
was made on several items of the test during the course of treatment to
judge, with reference to the school record and the parent's report, whether
there was improvement or not.
Accessory Examinations
Electroencephalography (EEG): Of the 530 patients in this series who received
EEG examination, 236 showed moderate-to-severe abnormality, with asymmetrical
bilateral waves. Spike and ware waves were found in patients with concomitant
epilepsy.
Skull CT scanning: Two hundred and twenty-three patients were subjected
to pretreatment CT scanning. Eighty-five of them showed different degrees
of pathological changes, including focal low density of the brain, widened
cerebral sulci, narrowed cerebral gyri, enlarged ventricles, and cystic
degeneration. Patients with concomitant monoparesis and cerebral hemiplegia
all showed abnormal CT findings.
Chromosome examination: Six affected children suspected of having a history
of genetic diseases were subjected to chromosomal karyotype analysis.
Four of them had chromosome abnormalities.
Method of Treatment and Results
Method of Treatment
All the patients were treated with Li's Prescription No.5 capsule only,
without any other medicines. Three to five capsules each time, three times
a day, oral administration for three successive months constitutes one
course of treatment. Follow-up study was made after two courses of treatment
to interpret therapeutic effectiveness. Some of the patients were given
EEG and CT reexamination. For those who had some but not satisfactory
results, additional one or two courses of treatment were given.
Results
Criteria for interpreting therapeutic effectiveness: (1) Notable effect:
Noticeable improvement in nervous dysfunction. Affected children who had
made marked progress in learning, school records, psychometry, and social
adaptability based on the feedback from teachers and parents fell into
this category; (2) effectiveness: showing improvement in behavior and
learning capacity without resulting in a huge hike in school work; and
(3) failure: showing no change in behavior and
learning capacity after treatment.
Of the 1 396 cases undergoing 2-4 courses of treatment, 1 253 had notable
effectiveness and 143 had some effectiveness, the effective
rate being 100% and the notably effective rate being 89.8% (Table 1).
Treatment with the drug has the following characteristics: (1) a better
curative effect on congenital MR; (2) a good curative effect for patient
aged less than 18 years; (3) a wonderful curative effect on MR caused
by chromosome abnormalitics; (4) promoting growth and development of the
organism and correcting abnormal physical signs, such as gain in body
height, enlargement of head circumference, correction of strabismus and
improvement in looks; (5) visual recovery of blindness due to optic atsophy;
(6) recovery of limb functions in patients with cerebral palsy; and (7)
correction of concomitant epilepsy and dysaudia.
Reexamination of EEG and CT made on part of the patients showed that 236
cases, especially those with concomitant epilepsy, had marked improvement
in EEG, with diminution or disappearance of spike and ware wave after
treatment and that 23 of the 85 cases showing abnormal CT findings had
some improvement after treatment, as manifested by reduction or disappearance
of focal low density of the brain, shallow cerebral sulci and widened
cerebral gyri (Table 2). In none of the cases did toxic reaction occur.
Table 1 Therapeutical analysis of children with MD
Patient's condition No.of cases No.of cases showing No.of cases showing
No.of
Notable effectiveness some effectiveness failures
Mild type (dull-wittedness) 92 92 0 0
Moderate type (dementia) 380 344 36 0
Severe type (idiocy) 924 817 107 0
Total 1 396 1 253 143 0
Table 2 Changes in EEG and CT before and after treatment
Item No.of cases No.of positive cases No.of improved cases Improvement
Examined before treatment after treatment rate (%)
EEG 530 236 151 64
CT 223 85 23 27.4
Typical cases
Case 1 Liao, a boy aged 5 years, had a history of high fever and convulsion
at 3, followed by hypophrenia, abnormal behavior and dyskinesia. The patient
had previously been diagnosed as having encephalopathic sequela, epilepsy,
etc. and treated with pyrithioxine hydrochloride, glutamic acid and
cytidine diaphosphate choline at several
hospitals in xi'an and Lanzhou with no response. On examination, he looked
dull with binocular strabismus, lockjaw and speech problem. He could only
utter mono-syllabic sounds now and then. Other symptoms included: lack
of response, inability to lift his head due to weak neck, upper limb spasm,
tight fists, adducted thumbs, flexed wrists, inability to stand up due
to weak lower limbs, intorsive feet with scissor's gait, weakened knee
reflex and positive bilateral Babinski's sign. EEG showed moderate abnormality,
CT scanning showed decreased white matter density in bilateral parieto-occipital
regions, and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) showed abnormal signal of
bilateral lenticular nucleus, Liao was diagnosed as having demyelinating
disease. He was given Li's Prescription No.5 capsule, 3 capsules each
time, three times a day, for 1 successive year. Follow-up study found
that he had had remarkable improvement in intelligence, his strabismus
had been corrected, jaws loosened, neck muscles strengthened, upper limb
spasm had disappeared, fingers had been flexible, and myodynamia of lower
limbs had been recovered. Walking steadily, he could move up and down
the stairs without stumble and ride a tricycle unaided for a few li's
distance. Having restored his linguistic function, he was able to speak
fluently and articulately and count numbers within 100. He could do simple
arithmetic, eat and dress without help, and play ball games and skip rope
with other children. EEG and CT reexamination showed no marked abnormalities.
Case 2 Zhang, a 7-year-old boy, born 6 weeks premature weighed only 1.4
kg at birth, had contracted neonatal jaundice and neonatal pneumonia on
day 7 after birth. Ten months after birth he still had no tooth eruption
and could neither creep nor raise his head because of the weak limbs and
maldevelopment. When he was 3 years old, he could neither speak nor walk,
and had poor comprehension. When he was 4 years and 6 months old, he could
only utter such monosyllabic sounds as Pa and Ma and still could not walk
alone. When first seen at the hospital, the patient made hoarse monosyllabic
sounds and sometimes screamed. Though hyperactive, he could not coordinate
his action well and had unstable gait. He was irritable, wilful and sialotic
with his tongue often hanging outside his mouth. He could not respond
to the call of nature and could not tell when he was hungry or full. Neuropsychiatric
examination showed a dull appearance, microcephaly, a head circumference
of 38 cm and a tower-shaped skull, depressed occiput, flat temporo-occiput,
obliquely upward ocular hypertelorism, bilateral paropsis, relatively
broader nose ala, and smaller, disarranged teeth. His four limbs had involuntary
movement. His upper limbs were intorted, muscular tension increased, both
thumbs adducted, and wrists flexed, with hyperreflexia of brachial biceps
and positive Hoffmann's sign. He showed scissors gait with intorted feet.
The muscle strength of the right lower limb was 2nd degree, that of the
left lower limb 3rd degree. He had hyperreflexia of knee jerk, hypermyotonia,
patellar and ankle clonus and positive bilateral Babinski's sign. EEG
showed mild abnormality. CT showed slightly broadened cerebral sulci.
Chromosome examination confirmed that the patient had 21-trisomy syndrome.
He was diagnosed as having extremely severe MR complicated with cerebral
palsy. After one year's treatment with Li's Prescription No.5 the affected
child had marked improvement in his intelligence, awareness and understanding.
He could do two-digit addition and subtraction. At ordinary times he liked
singing and watching TV programs for children and could retell the central
content of the story he had seen. He became enunciative and fluent. His
head circumference increased to 48 cm, the morphological development of
his head and facial organs became as normal as that of normal children.
Involuntary movement of the extremities disappeared, and gait and posture
returned to normal. He moved his hands freely, walked almost steadily.
His muscular tension was reduced and his myodynamia was restored. Babinski's
sign (+) was restricted only to his right side. CT reexamination showed
cerebral sulci and fissures shrunk. EEG reexamination was basically normal.
Case 3 Yang, a 6-year-old boy, a premature infant of 206 days, weighed
1.6 kg at birth, could smile ten months after birth, raised his head at
one year of age, had closure of bregmatic fontanel at two years and six
months of age, could not stand up alone. His parents were healthy and
denied history of familial hereditary disease and consanguineous marriage.
At the time of examination the affected child was found to be unable to
take care of himself at all, hyporeactive to external stimulation, unaware
of hungry or full, cold or warm, unclear in enunciation with hoarse monosyllabic
sounds, unable to express a complete idea, hyperactive, irritable, sialotic
with his tongue often hanging outside his mouth, and non-responsive to
the call of nature, and he was often found to bite his finger nails and
dirty things to eat, to be unable to stand up alone and often to imitate
and repeat some simple actions. The affected child didn't cooperate with
the doctor during physical examination. Neuropsychiatric examination showed
no response, apathy, presence of pain, head circumference 35.5 cm, orbital
hypertelorism, low and flat nose root, a protruding tongue with laceration
on its surface and salivation, smaller and disarranged teeth, deformity
of ear, ear margin 2.3 cm, involuntary movement of the extremities, torsion
spasm of both upper limbs, showing "airplane-shaped muscle"
backwards, chicken's-claw type of both hands, hypermyotonia, flexed wrists,
hyperreflexia of brachial biceps and positive Hoffmann's sign. His hands
were short and broad, thumbs 2.0 cm, index fingers 2.6 cm, middle fingers
2.8 cm, ring fingers 2.6 cm and little fingers 1.8 cm. His body height
was 97 cm, both hands were one-line palms, both feet had plantar flexion
and intorsion, with hyperreflexia of knee jerk, hypermyotonia and positive
bilateral Babinski's sign. He was diagnosed as having (1) extremely severe
MR and (2) 21-trisomy syndrome. After six month's treatment, the affected
child grew and developed rapidly, his intelligence improved notably, he
was quick in action and active in nature. Having restored his linguistic
function, he was able to speak fluently and articulately. Such symptoms
as protruding tongue, salivation and biting nails had disappeared. His
answer kept to the point and could count numbers within 100. He could
sing children's songs and do simple arithmetic. His motor function of
extremities was restored to normal, involuntary movement of the extremities
and torsion spasm of the upper extremities had disappeared with resultant
free action. His body height was 110 cm., head circumference 48 cm, right
ear margin 6.3 cm, left ear margin 6.2 cm, thumb 4.1 cm, middle finger
5.2 cm, index finger 4.7 cm and ring finger 4.6 cm, the increase of fingers
being significant.
Case 4 Zhou, male, aged 18 years, had had high fever (41.2¡æ) due to common
cold at 6 months of life, followed by frequent episodes of epilepsy one
month later, which had been treated in many ways but failed to respond
to medical treatment. At the time of examination, the patient showed a
physiognomy of dementia with right strabismus and poor vision. He had
rightward obliquity, chicken-claw type of both hands without power of
gripping, hypermyotonia, torsion spasm, rightward-abduction gait of lower
limbs with both heel failing to touch the ground, bilateral hyperreflexia
of knee jerk, and positive Babinski's sign which was manifest on the right
side. CT scanning showed broaden cerebral sulci and fissures, and EEG
examination showed moderate abnormality. He was diagnosed as having severe
type of MD complicated with cerebral palsy and was given Li's Prescription
No.5. According to the parent's report, this medicine began to produce
effect after oral administration for two successive months, and six months
later intelligence and functions of extremities and speech recovered.
One year later strabismus was corrected, and vision was restored to 1.5
(both eyes). He became articulate and fluent. His torsion spasm disappeared,
muscular tension decreased, gait stabilized, and pathologic sign disappeared.
The patient had a bright and cheerful disposition, was initiative and
liked singing and dancing. He has started school and got good school record.
He often initiatively helped his parents in doing housework, he could
go shopping alone just as a normal person. CT scanning showed cerebral
sulci and fissures shrunk, and EEG reexamination showed normal findings.
Case 5 Yang, a six years old girl, had been diagnosed as having (1) arachnoid
cyst, (2) obstructive hydrocephlus, and (3) functional cerebral palsy
at Beijing Medical University. On examination she was found to be unable
to walk by changing step, to have no linguistic function, no cognitive
ability and no faculty of understanding. She had a large malformed head,
a head circumference of 58 cm, a markedly leftwards oblique face, strabismus
and diminution of vision (left eye 0.2, right eye 0.3), and irregular
features. After treatment with Li's Prescription No.5 for three successive
months, functions of extremities, speech and consciousness got notable
restoration, and it was unimaginable that her head circumference had reduced
to 51 cm, that she had had a regular face and features and that her strabismus
had been corrected with improved vision.
Discussion
Mental retardation (MR) or hypophrenia is internationally defined as the
state of those whose intellectual powers fall significantly below the
level of the same age on a standardized intelligence test with accompanying
defect in adaptive capacity (WHO, 1985). (3) In accordance with the above-mentioned
definition, the diagnostic criteria for MR should correspondingly include
three aspects: (1) the fall of intellectual powers significantly below
the level of the same age is that IQ is lower than the mean by 2 standard
deviations, with an IQ below 70; (2) the adaptive capacity is lower than
the social normal values, there are marked defects in one's own life and
in practising social duties; (3) MR occurs in the stage of developmental
age, namely, under 18 years of age. (4) It is evident that the diagnosis
of MR should consider the following three aspects: (1) Only in the cases
whose conditions conform to the three diagnostic criteria can the diagnosis
of MR be mode. Simple low IQ with good adaptive capacity cannot be diagnosed
as MR. Decline in intelligence after adult stage is not known as MR but
as dementia. (2) The diagnosis of MR is chiefly psychological and behavioral
and not simple medical evaluation. (3) MR is not a permanent intellectual
disturbance in all cases, and the IQ is changeable. The vast majority
of patients in this series were under 18 years of age, a small number
of patients, though aged over 18 years, had their disease in childhood;
therefore, their diagnosis of MR is in keeping with the criteria.
Intelligence is a multifactorial genetic trait and the result of interaction
of heredity and environment. Heredity determines the attainable level
of intelligence under the optimum conditions, namely, latent energy. Environment
determines the extent to which the latent energy can really be developed,
improvement of environment facilitates the development of intelligence.
(5) There is no consistent idea on definition of intelligence. Intelligence
is a power, behaviors that reflect intelligence are manifested by the
following aspects: capacity of learning, capacity of acquiring knowledge
and benefiting from it, capacity of thinking and reasoning, and ability
to solve problems and adapt environmental changes, these belonging in
the field of cognition. Adaptive capacity (behavior) is assessed on the
basis of people of the same age and cultural background to interpret the
extent to which one is able to attain his own life and practise social
duties. Adaptive behavior does not simply take medicine as the index but
takes the requirements made on oneself by social environment in which
he lives as standard. Full understanding of the implications of intelligence
and adaptive capacity is highly helpful to the interpretation of therapeutic
effectiveness as well as to the diagnosis of disease.
MR, a symptom, has many etiologic factors including, according to the
international standardized etiologic classification of MR (WHO, 1985),
(1) infection and poisoning, (2) injury and physical factors, (3) metabolic
and nutritional factors (including hereditary metabolic disease), (4)
macroscopically detected encephalopathy (including hereditary degeneration),
(5) congenital factors of unknown causes (deformity, congenital idiocy
syndrome, neural tube defect), (6) chromosome disease, (7) perinatal factors,
(8) concomitant mental diseases, (9) adverse environmental factors, social
mental damage, social deprival, etc. , and (10) others. It can be seen
from above that, other than the bio-medical factors, about 20%-35% of
MR patients can be found to have medical abnormalities, which are severe
type in most cases, with chromosome disease accounting for 15%-20% of
the total, the most common being 21-trisome syndrome. Those without medical
abnormal findings account for about 65.8% of the total, and about 50%
are due to social environmental factors. In addition, part of MR patients
are of unknown causes. It has also been reported (4) that in the etiological
factors of MR definite genetic defect makes up about 37%, environmental
factors constitute 20%, and the remaining 43% are of unknown causes. In
this series of patients, 1 030 cases (73.8%) were found to have had a
history of difficult labor, delivery suffocation, premature labor or forceps
delivery; 285 cases (20.4%) were found to have had a history of high fever,
convulsion or diarrhea; and the remaining cases (5.5%) were of unknown
causes. As condition is limited, it is impossible to make chromosome analysis
in all cases; in the six cases examined, however, 4 were found to have
chromosome abnormalities, two of them had 21-trisome syndrome (cases 2,
3). It is obvious that chromosome abnormalities are a key factor in the
pathogenesis of MR. Moreover, MR caused by prenatal and perinatal factors
accounts for vast majority of the cases, indicating that prevention of
MR should be focused on perinatal health care.
In addition to abnormalities of intelligence and social adaptive capacity,
MR has some concomitant somatic diseases, the most important are the three
kinds of diseases: (1) Sensory disturbance In this series of patients,
251 (18%) had dysopia with optic atrophy. (2) Dyskinesia In addition to
the common clumsiness in movement, MR has rigidity, ataxia and other disturbances.
In this series of MR patients, cerebral palsy was seen in 382 (27.4%)
cases. (3) Epilepsy Epileptic attack is very common in the disease, especially
in severe cases. It is reported that about one third of patients have
epileptic attack. It is more frequently encountered in MR due to brain
injury. In our series of patients, there were 264 cases (18.9%) of concomitant
epilepsy, slightly lower than the figure reported in literature, and among
the factors inducing epilepsy, the most common is the high fever caused
by "common cold", "pneumonia" and "toxic dysentery".
No sufficient attention was devoted to the morphology and electrophysiology
of the brain of the affected children. The author made CT and EEG observation
on part of the cases and found that no marked abnormalities were detected
in the vast majority of the affected children but that in extremely severe
MR children, especially in those with concomitant cerebral palsy, shallowed
cerebral gyri, deepened cerebral sulci and fissures, local cerebromalacia
and hydrocepalus were observed in CT scanning and in the affected children
with concomitant epilepsy pathological spike and ware wave were detected
in EEG examination.
The diagnosis of MR should be carried out at the same time of treatment
or intervention, this being the process of comprehensive multidiscipline
diagnosis and treatment. The purpose of treatment is to make, as far as
possible, the affected child take care of himself, to improve his intelligence
to the maximum limit, and to learn the skills of communicating with people
and of adapting social life. Method of treatment includes pharmacotherapy
and psychological education. Because MR patients are, for the most part,
of unknown causes and even if the cause of disease is known, the symptoms
that have developed cannot usually be treated by the method of removing
etiologic factors. Therefore, no specific therapy is available at present.
In Western medicine, drugs with action of promoting cerebral metabolism
such as vitamin B6, pyrithioxine hydrochloride, glutamic acid and cytidine
diphosphate choline are commonly used but they have no notable therapeutic
effectiveness. For some accompanying symptoms of MR, the Western medicine
can only give expectant treatment, for examples, behavior abnormalities,
restless leg syndrome and hypoprosexia are treated with nervous stimulants,
epilepsy with antiepileptics and mental symptoms with tranquilizers. Treatment
of MR with traditional Chinese medicine seems to have its distinctive
qualities. In this aspect, scholars at home have done large quantities
of research work and obtained encouraging results. It must be, however,
noted that treatment of the disease remains in the stage of clinical observation
at present. The use of decoction in the form of prepared drugs is inconvenient
for long-term use. Other forms of prepared drugs convenient for administration,
carry and storage such as granule preparation, syrut, tablet, pill, etc.
must be used for the affected child's persistent administration. Methods
of treatment include (6) a special prescription for a particular disease,
treatment with syndrome differentiation, acupuncture and moxibustion,
point-injection therapy, ear needling and auricular-plaster therapy. A
special prescription for a particular disease refers to a special prescription
or fixed form of prepared drugs composed of effective drugs screened according
to experience through the ages and clinical data and from different angles
for treatment of disease, this being the method more frequently used at
present. According to various reports in literature, (6,7,8) treatment
starts mainly with (1) tonifying the kidney, replenishing vital essence
and marrow, (2) tonifying the heart, invigorating the spleen and inducing
resuscitation, (3) tonifying the viscera with viscera and (4) promoting
blood circulation by removing blood stasis, restoring consciousness and
dispelling phlegm. Treatment with syndrome differentiation, though it
can be directed against the patient's condition and can be individualized
in treatment, is difficult to systematize, scientize and popularize. In
view of this restriction of treating MR with traditional Chinese medicine
at the moment, the author has, based on many years' research with great
concentration and repeated practices, successfully developed "Li's
Prescription No.5" capsule which is easy to be administered for treating
MR. This drug, absorbing the quintessence of traditional Chinese medicine
and using the achievements of modern medical scientific researches, has
yielded unexpected results in clinical application. It has broken a fresh
path for treating MR with traditional Chinese medicine, enriched the theories
of traditional Chinese medicine, and demonstrated the huge potentiality
contained in treatment of disease with traditional Chinese medicine. In
our series of patients, the notably effective rate was 89.8% and the effective
rate was 100%, with all the patients highly improved in intelligence,
speech and physical development. Moreover, dyskinesia of extremities and
hypoacusis were markedly improved, strabismus was corrected, blindness
due to optic atrophy regained its vision. The medication was particularly
effective for those patients with concomitant epilepsy, with a consolidation
rate of 100%. What is more, the marked effectiveness of the medication
is also reflected in the morphology and electrophysiology of the brain,
with EEG improvement rate reaching 64%, CT improvement rate reaching 27.4%.
The author also found that a better therapeutic effectiveness was obtained
in MR caused by congenital factors than by acquired factors. It is worth
mentioning that this drug was highly effective in treating MR due to chromosome
abnormalities as well (case 2 and case 3) and promoted physical development,
as seen in case 3 in which after treatment the affected child not only
regained his motor function of extremities and linguistie function and
improved his intelligence but also had great changes in physical signs,
as was observed in follow-up study in which the head circumference was
found to be 48 cm, an increase by 12.5 cm; ear margin 6.3 cm in length,
an increase by 2.7 cm; body height 118 cm, an increase by 22 cm; and fingers
were found to have an average increase of 2.3 cm. In addition, those aged
under 18 years had a significant therapeutic effectiveness. This breaks
through the age limit in MR treatment, differing from the reports of many
domestic scholars. Wang et al. (7) reported that of the 70 children with
atelencephalia treated by differentiation of symptoms and signs, 23 were
notably effective and 37 were effective, the total effective rate being
85.8% and that the smaller the age and the earlier the treatment, the
more notable the effect in treating MR due to congenital factors and with
dyskinesia as the dominant manifestation. Zhou et al. (8) also reported
similar findings. The author is of the opinion that the present medication
has blazed new trails in three aspects: (1) The therapeutic effectiveness
is unexpected, the effective rate being 100%; (2) it breaks through the
age limit in MR treatment, those aged under 18 years all had a better
therapeutic effectiveness; and (3) in addition to the redevelopment of
the central nervous system, it promotes the redevelopment of the whole
organism.
The miraculous effectiveness of Li's Prescription No.5 defies any explanation
using existing theories. In an attempt to explain the encephalic and body
development as well as their normal functioning, the author boldly puts
forward a new hypothesis (called Li's theory for short), the main point
of which is that there might exist in the brain an "adjusting point"
which controls the normal development and functioning of the central nervous
system, just as the central nervous system governs the development and
functioning of the whole organism. The hypofunction of the "adjusting
point" will make an impact on the development and functioning of
the central nervous system, followed by the occurrence of disturbances
of perception and thinking of human brain, manifested as feeblemindedness
and affective disorder and loss of control of cerebral domain governing
somatic movement, resulting in extremity dyskinesia, hypoacusis and blindness.
The hyperfunction of the "adjusting point" will lead to the
occurrence of over-excitation of central nervous system, thus developing
different types of psychonosema such as affective disorder and epilepsy.
It is, therefore, reasonable to regard the "adjusting point"
as the center of the central nervous system. The definition of the "adjusting
point" is functional and not anatomical, it may be a high-energy
magnetic field in the brain which interferes with all the activities of
the brain in the form of electromagnetic wave and maintains electric potential
gradient on both sides of neurolemma. Advancing the hypothesis is based
on the following facts: Firstly, the activities of human brain, whether
those of higher thinking or those of controlling the body, are based on
bioelectric activity, the production and transmission of which necessarily
forms electro-magnetic field in the ambient space and thus makes an impact
on the function and metabolism of adjacent neurons(9) ; secondly, despite
the deep thorough studies on the formation and metabolism of the brain
in modern science, the structural complexity of human brain and the limitations
of research methods impose restrictions on the understanding of the cerebral
functions, or rather, the cerebral latent energy, such as the extraordinary
powers and the phenomenon of deep breathing exercises of man; and despite
the fact that the one-position sign governing somatic movement can easily
localize the functional position of human brain, the domain of the higher
thinking activities of human brain cannot be accurately localized because
of the involvement of extensive synergism of the brain, this bringing
about some difficulties and remaining to be explored further; thirdly,
the fact that central nervous system has some plasticity, (10) namely,
power of regeneration, suggests that regulation of the function and development
of neurons by "adjusting point" has some material base; and
fourthly, lack of marked abnormality in cerebral morphology in many patients
with mental retardation, especially in those having chromosome abnormalities,
indicates that there may be neuronal hypometabolism and hypofunction only
and that there exists possibility of further improving such hypometabolism
and hypofunction. According to this hypothesis, the author is of the opinion
that MR, whether congenital or acquired, all leads to anion-cation imbalance
in the brain, thus interferes with the function of the "adjusting
point", with development of abnormalities of neuronal function and
metabolism (such as microcirculatory disturbance, pathological enhancement
of free radical reaction, and reduction of cytotrophic supply). Those
with accompanying somatic symptoms (such as cerebral palsy, strabismus,
blindness, etc) have particular nerve mass and the organic lesion of fiber
yet. It is, therefore, the key to treating MR to correct the anion-cation
imbalance in the brain, the wonderful therapeutic effectiveness of Li's
Prescription No.5 in treating MR in turn confirms this. This elevation
of anion-cation index by Li's Prescription No.5 leads to enhancement of
potential gradient, functional improvement of the "adjusting point",
and acceleration of transformation and transmission of electromagnetic
field, thus directly promoting the regeneration and functioning of the
central nervous system. The routes by which Li's Prescription No.5 takes
effect are: (1) opening the blood-brain barrier and increasing quantity
of entry of such nutrients as amino acids, peptides and phospholipids
to make the residual neurons regenerate and function; (2) regulating microcirculation
of the brain, raising the energy metabolism of the brain, increasing oxygen
supply, and enhancing the activity of nerve cells and their sensitivity
to external stimulation to make the nerve cells in dormant state and the
damaged nerve cells revive and to mobilize the latent energy of the brain;
(3) promoting synthesis of neurotrophic factors to strengthen regeneration
of nerve cells; (4) regulating ions (such as Ca, Na, K, etc.) transport
in the brain and restoring the bioelectric activity of nerve cells and
its transmission: (5) eliminating noxious substances such as free radicals
in the brain and restoring the function of nerve cell membrance; and (6)
mobilizing the pituitary function to increase the synthesis and release
of growth hormone and facilitate physical development. This hypothesis
might explain the patients' post-treatment rise of intelligence, enhancement
of social adaptive ability, restoration of extremity and speech function,
correction of strabismus, improvement of hearing, regaining vision in
those with optic atrophy, surpassing normal level in intelligence in individual
patients, physical development, and the return to normal of physical signs.
This drug has a dual-directional regulation: skull exceeding normal size
shrinks (case 5) and that smaller than normal size enlarges (case 2),
this being a strong evidence.
To sum up, the author used "Li's Prescription No.5" to treat
MR and obtained wonderful therapeutic effectiveness, the notably effective
rate being 89.8% and the effective rate being 100%. Patients aged less
than 18 years all had therapeutic effectiveness. The medication was highly
effective for those with concomitant blindness and epilepsy. More notably,
the medication was able to promote redevelopment of the organism of affected
children with microsoma due to chromosome abnormalities. In addition,
the notable therapeutic effectiveness was also reflected in the anatomy
and electrophysiology of the affected children's brain, with CT improvement
rate reaching 27.4% and EEG improvement rate reaching 64%. The author
advances the theory of "adjusting point" on the development
and functioning of human brain (Li's theory). The occurrence of MR is
related to the hypofunction of the "adjusting point". Li's Prescription
No.5 makes intelligence of child with fe4eblemindedness recover or even
exceed the normal level, it certainly makes normal persons more clever
by developing the latent function of the brain. This fully suggests a
vast range of prospects for developing "Li's Prescription No.5"
to serve the whole society. In addition, Li's theory might be used as
theoretical guidance or for reference in the diagnosis and treatment of
other diseases of the central nervous system and somatic diseases, and
this remains to be jointly explored by people of the same profession.
Reference
(1) Li Pu. Foreign Medicine, Series Genetics, 1990, (4): 169.
(2) Xu Junmian. J of Traditional Chin Med, 1985, (1): 38.
(3) Zuo Qihua. J of Appl Pediat, 1989, (1): 31.
(4) Wang Xiaoyun. Tianjin Medicine, 1992, (8): 494.
(5) Xia Zhenjun, et al. Applied Psychiatry. 1st ed; Shanghai, Shanghai
Scientific and Technological Publishing House, 1990, pp 355-371.
(6) Qian Dayu. J of Traditional Chin Med, 1990, (7): 53.
(7) Wang Lie, et al. J of New Traditional Chin Med, 1984, (4): 27.
(8) Zhou Xiting, et al. Shanghai J of Traditional Chin Med, 1988, (1):
10.
(9) Su Zhufei. Foreign Medicine, Series Pediatrics, 1982, (1): 1.
(10) Xiao Xiaming, et al. Foreign Medicine, series Pediatrics, 1981, (1):
16.
|